Showing posts with label Moneyball. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Moneyball. Show all posts

The Plot Holes of Moneyball

No one has ever been more upset to lose reliver Jason Isringhausen than the characters in Bennett Miller's 2011 classic Moneyball. It's not that the Oakland A's lost borderline Hall of Famers Jason Giambi and Johnny Damon to free agency after the 2001 season, but also Jason Isringhausen?! My stars, how will Billy Beane ever recover!?

Listen, I get it. In the film, the 2002 Oakland A's appear to be one of the worst teams in the league held together by rubber bands and Scotch tape. The film needs to creatively, yet realistically show the internal struggle that was at the heart of Michael Lewis's New York Times Best Seller of the same name: a team fighting back against the traditionalism of Baseball using advanced statistics. As such, a closer like Jason Isringhausen needs to be lumped in with Giambi and Damon and his loss needs to be also treated with the utmost reverence. 

In reality, the 2002 A's, even without Jason Giambi and Johnny Damon, and yes, even without Jason Isringhausen, were a damn good team. Oakland still had stud third baseman Eric Chavez, future World Series MVP Jermaine Dye, 2002 MVP Miguel Tejada and one of the best rotations since the mid-90's Atlanta Braves including a young Aaron Harang and Cory Liddle and the fearsome trio of Mark Mulder, Tim Hudson, and 2002 AL Cy Young winner Barry Zito. 

The lack of players not discussed in the film and the rotation that's rarely discussed in the book as well seems to be the main sticking point with a lot of fans. Sure Scott Hatteberg and David Justice were fine players, but you're not going to mention that both the AL MVP and the AL Cy Young came from this team as well? How dare you sir!

Again, I get it. It's hard to adapt a book that's all over the place that Moneyball actually is while also still including its themes all while making it palatable for a mainstream audience. As such, the film overwhelming is a creative success, even though it comes at the expense of the majority of excellent players.

But that's not what this blog post is about. I'm not here to discuss the differences between the film and what actually occurred in real life. I'm here to discuss the plot holes that exist solely within the text of the film. If you want more information about many major differences between the film and historical record, I'll put a list together at the end. But for now, here's the glaring errors I notice when watching the film for the 50th time. These are the plot holes of Moneyball.

Moneyball: The Movie Trailer

Get excited

Book Review: The Extra 2%

DME and I have been excitedly waiting for Jonah Keri's new book The Extra 2%: How Wall Street Strategies Took a Major League Team from Worst to First since the summer of 2010 when Mr. Keri first starting pimping it. I think it was supposed to be released in 2010, but the book ended up being released in March of 2011. I don't know who's decision it was but I'm glad it eventually got released so late so that the book included information from the 2010 baseball season.

Don't worry ladies and germs, I will not be giving away any spoilers. I know some GOI readers would like to read this book and haven't yet, so don't worry, I'm not ruining anything for you.

This book is about the Tampa Bay Rays (formerly Devil Rays) and follows the franchise from it's entire existence. The book is called The Extra 2% because it's essentially the reason the Rays have started winning since current owner Stuart Sternberg bought out original owner Vincent Naimoli.

On the back cover that has advanced praises for the book, Buster Olney writes:
The Tampa Bay Rays- with their ma-and-pa-sized budget- have gone head to head with baseball's two superpowers, the Yankees and the Red Sox. In the superb The Extra 2%, Jonah Keri explains how and why in a way that will remind readers of Michael Lewis' Moneyball
This book is not Moneyball. I repeat, this book is not Moneyball. Moneyball by Michael Lewis is certainly the most influential baseball book today and for my money the best as well. Moneyball was so great because it followed a team and its GM (Billy Beane and the Oakland A's) and told the reader how a small market team can be run successfully and how advanced statistics can be used to further that goal. Despite the title and several chapters in Mr. Keri's book, The Extra 2% does not really do that.

If you listen to Jonah Keri in interviews when he's promoting this book, he fully explains what this book is: It's a collection of stories surrounding the entire history of the Rays franchise. Personally, I found the best chapters the ones where Mr. Keri explains to the readers why the Rays are as successful as they are now and the strategies they employ to get there, but the book is so much more.

The book has several chapters regarding the personal life and background of current manager Joe Maddon, the three main people controlling the team right now (Stuart Sternberg, Matthew Silverman, and Andrew Friedman) as well as the original owner Vincent Naimoli and several chapters regarding Tropicana Field (the stadium where the Rays call home in St. Petersberg), how the stadium came to be and how a franchise ended up in the Tampa/St. Pete area to begin with.

The book (obviously) goes in chronological order so the beginning about how the Rays came to be and how Mr. Naimoli ran the team started off the book. Personally, I didn't care. I just wanted to get to the good stuff about how the team is currently run. To me the book started off slow but you needed the background to get to the good stuff. To me, it was like the history of fantasy baseball in another great book Fantasyland. It's interesting and cool to know and helps set the background, but overall I just didn't care about it and I just wanted to get to the good stuff (the Tout Wars game in particular in Fantasyland).

For those of you (who like me) were unaware of Vincent Naimoli's reputation as an owner, the book paints a great picture of what a dick this guy was and you see many reasons for why the Rays were so bad as long as they were. Although I will say this, I don't think the end of his regime got enough credit like it should. As bad as the Naimoli regime was (oh, and it was) they still drafted guys like Carl Crawford, Jeremy Hellickson, James Shields, B.J. Upton, Wade Davis, and Reid Brignac and traded away Victor Zambrano to the Mets for Scott Kazmir which help form the nucleus of this Rays team from 2008 to now. The book spends pages and chapters shitting on former Devil Rays GM Chuck Lamaar (and he's very candid about what a bad GM he was) yet glosses over the successes he had.

But going back to Moneyball, the one major annoyance I had with the book is the self- (hmm, what's the word I'm looking for) realization (?) of the existence of Moneyball. When you write a baseball book about how a small market baseball team overcomes the financial odds to become a powerhouse, you're book is inevitably going to be compared to Moneyball. Therefore, you have to at least mention it or realize the impact it had or something. And Jonah Keri does do that. But I felt like he did it to a fault. There were constant references to Moneyball and to Billy Beane that at first I liked, but grew weary and annoyed by it as the book progressed.

Overall, I throughly enjoyed this book an I recommend it to every baseball fan. I was a fan of Jonah Keri before this book and I'm a bigger fan of him now after this book. Obviously, Moneyball is still a better book but like I said, it's an unfair comparison. The Dark Knight was a far better movie than Batman Begins but that doesn't stop me from enjoying the first Christopher Nolan Batman movie. The stories were extremely interesting and I loved to hear how this new Rays regime worked its magic to win as many games as they had in the past three seasons.

You can purchase the book on Amazon here

One last note: Major League Baseball is a giant fuck. I know all major sports leagues are, but... fuck the MLB.

Moneyball The Movie Update: Actor Chris Pratt Joins Cast

According to a promotional representative working with Sony films on the motion picture production of the award winning sabermetrics novel Moneyball, Chris Pratt has joined the cast of the film to play former A's 1B Scott Hatteberg (the guy Joey Votto unseated in Cincinnati in 2008). Per the press release:
Los Angeles (July 13, 2010) – Chris Pratt star of the NBC hit comedy series “Parks and Recreation” has joined the cast of “Moneyball” which includes Brad Pitt, Robyn Wright, Jonah Hill and Philip Seymour Hoffman. Pratt will star as former Oakland Athletics 1st Baseman Scott Hatteberg.

The Bennett Miller-directed baseball project is being produced by Scott Rudin and Michael DeLuca and was written by Steven Zaillian and Aaron Sorkin, based on Michael Lewis’ 2003 nonfiction book about Oakland Athletics GM Billy Beane and his strategy for building a successful team without paying players enormous salaries.

Chris Pratt is quickly establishing himself as one of today’s most versatile young actors in film and television. In film, Pratt just completed shooting a role opposite Anna Faris in the Fox comedy What’s Your Number also starring Chris Evans. Pratt will next be seen in the Universal Pictures film Young Americans also starring Faris and Topher Grace due out in January, 2011. Additional films Pratt has starred in include Wanted, Bride Wars and Jennifer’s Body. Chris Pratt is represented by Mosaic, CAA and attorney Peter Nelson.
I'm excited for the release of this film, which has been in the works for years now, but am sincerely hoping it takes a less overly dramatic direction than last year's The Blind Side, based on a different Michael Lewis book.

Billy Beane doesn't just draft baseball players (he also drafts women)




As an avid follower of the Moneyball Movie genesis (there's other posts about it floating around this blog without the proper tags for some reason...), I was absolutely devastated when I found out that the movie was initially canceled. Although the film seemed surreal (Brad Pitt, Steven Soderbergh, Dmitri Martin, Scott Hatteberg...what?) and although Moneyball seemed like it would be the absolutely last book ever turned into a movie, stranger things have been accomplished. Unfilmable movies like Watchmen and A Clockwork Orange became great films.

Alas, I digress. The movie has been re-greenlighted without Soderbergh on board. What shocks me, however, and provides the basis for this post, is that, as an avid Moneyball movie tracker, I missed this amazing article which revealed the existence of a Moneyball sex scene in the film's original draft!

A PDF of the script (which has since been taken down) was floating around the internet at the time, which
"...even includes a scene in which the Oakland GM hits up an Outback Steakhouse in Cleveland with Paul DePodesta and orders a Bloomin' Onion.

Later, Zaillian portrays Beane doing the most logical thing after eating a plate of fried onions with tangy sauce ... having sex with the waitress who served it to him."

Classic, right? The best part of The Big League Stew's article is the rationalization of why this scene was probably cut from the rewrite:
Perhaps Soderbergh deleted this scene and Pascal thought the absence of chain restaurant-related romance would hurt the film's test scores among women?
We wouldn't want a movie about baseball statistics and 30 year old men who live in their mom's basements to alienate the female audience with a sex scene now, would we?

Jackie MacMullan is on my list

Jackie MacMullan was on Around the Horn today debating whether Mark Reynolds' new record of 206 single season strikeouts is really a bad thing. Most the panalists agreed that it really doesnt matter given his 43 homers on the season. However, Mrs. MacMullan said that you would never see Mark Reynolds' name in the book Moneyball.

Uhhhhhh, wouldn't Mark Reynolds be the perfect guy to put into Moneyball? This guy is Jack Cust on steroids, wait Cust is on steroids. This guy is Jack Cust on myostatin inhibitors.
His walk rate increases every year up to 12% this year, K rate increases every year up to 38% and his iso jumped to the .300 range. He even has 24 steals this year, which is anti-moneyball, but he steals at a 73% clip which is satisfactory. If you want to play for the 3-run homer, Mark Reynolds is your guy. I think MacMullan meant Chris Davis is not a Moneyball guy.

The .300 iso level needs to have a cool name like the Mendoza line. I recommend Jimmie Foxx who had a career .284 iso and 6 seasons over 300. We can call is the "double X" line. Awesome

Must read article

If you like baseball, you may want to read this.

Moneyball: The Movie

When I first heard that Hollywood was making a Moneyball movie, I thought it was a joke. But then Brad Pitt was signed to play Billy Beane and Steven Soderbergh was signed on to direct, which left me scratching my forehead.

Well the bizarre and befuddling nature of this film continues, as it was announced today that Paul DePodesta would be played by none other than Demetri Martin. Are we sure this isn't some elaborate practical joke than John Kruk and Steve Phillips are playing on us people who live in their mom's basements? Demetri Martin? Really?

Also, how is this the first Moneyball tagged post???

Also also, Scott Hatteberg and David Justice will play themselves in the film. This movie is going to monumentally suck. I can't wait to see it!